This thread is ONLY for theories and trials of the Under Giant recipe. I contributed something similar with the Aegir Trident. I have heard the Under Giant uses 3 different items: 2 gifts and 1 non-gift. I have heard theories that it uses Frost Giant and/or Elder Frost Giant. So I went and tested Frost Giant with some of my gifts, starting with Frost Giant + Thor Amulet: Viking Dagger (Viking Dagger used in another recipe) (missing Mead Horn) Viking Tunic (Thor Amulet) (missing Longbow) Viking Axes Leather Helm Poison Arrows Battle Chainmail (missing Trained Hawk) Rabbit Shield (missing Wooden Rabbit Amulet) (missing Leather Armbands) (Skull Dagger used in another recipe) Skull Tunic (missing Zombie Scorpion) War Boots Silver Armband War Belt Kite Shield Wolf Skin Cloak Gold Necklace Freyja's Tears Byggvir Ale (missing Drakkar Figurehead) Viking War Helm War Dog Vanir Statue Golden Apple of Youth Battle Swine Torch Silver Ornament North Star Charm (Iwaz Rune is used in a different recipe) Northern Knot Charm Sacred Well Lump of Coal Nordic Crossle Pendant Scroll of Vanir Knowledge Advent Wreath Blessed Oil Hiking Boots Pack Horse Odin's Mask The above items FAILED to make anything with Frost Giant and Thor Amulet. Also, I am missing some gifts...not sure why. Maybe I just overlooked them. I believe I have gone through ALL currently gift-able items, either ruling them out or stating that I lacked them There are other items that used to be gift-able (like Bonfire, which I tested) but are no longer available. And, to the best of my knowledge, no recipe in either Viking or Pirate Clan uses an ingredient that another recipe used. Yes, a recipe might use the RESULT of another, but they don't have the same ingredients. I have also tested: Frost Giant + Freyja's Tears + Hiking Boots Frost Giant + Northern Knot Charm + Freyja's Tears Frost Giant + Odin's Mask + Freyja's Tears Frost Giant + Freyja's Tears + Blessed Oil Could the Under Giant use a Blacksmith Warrior? Like "Land's End Sentinel"? That's the only one possible... Anyone have hints or failed combinations? Please list them!